
O'Neal debate based on flawed logic
By Conrad Brunner | Dec. 3, 2007
Let’s put something to rest, because it’s starting to get a little out of hand.
This theory the Pacers are a better team without Jermaine O'Neal is based on flawed logic.
![]() |
Some would point to the 5-1 record in games he’s missed this season as evidence the new system works better in his absence, and claim the 4-8 record when he’s played only reinforces that fact.
You are what you are and records don’t lie, but this is an example of adding two and two and getting 22.
The fact of the matter is the Pacers haven’t really had O’Neal all season long. When he’s been on the floor he hasn’t been anything close to 100 percent. And J.O. at 50 percent is, well, Mark Blount. The point being, any judgment on O’Neal’s ability to fit with, and contribute to, the team as constituted under Jim O’Brien, must be withheld until the real J.O. finally stands up.
Given his performance against the Clippers Sunday, when he reported no knee pain for the first time this season and was battling the after-effects of a shoulder stinger from Friday’s game in Seattle, it appears he’s getting to his feet. O’Neal scored 20 points with 15 rebounds and the Pacers outscored the Clippers by 23 points when he was on the floor.
So give it some time. That the Pacers have managed to go 9-9 while adapting to a 180-degree change in offensive philosophy and getting relatively limited contributions from their franchise big man is a good thing. It’s safe to assume that, as O’Neal regains his form, the Pacers will only get better. If not, then we’ll talk.
But if you insist on obsessing about the won-lost record with and without him, consider this: since the beginning of the 2005-06 season, the Cavaliers are 6-3 without LeBron James. Somehow, I doubt this debate is raging in Cleveland.
REGGIE MAKING MORE HEADLINES IN NEW YORK
![]() |
Reggie referred to the Knicks as “a league-wide joke” in an interview with the New York Daily News last week – and this was before they were demolished by the Celtics on TNT, with Miller at courtside serving as the analyst.
"All I know is that Isiah (Thomas) has the talent to make them a playoff-caliber team," Miller said. "With the talent New York has, they should easily be in the top six.”
Thomas, who of course coached Miller when both were with the Pacers from 2000-03, didn’t take his former player’s comments personally.
![]() |
“I'm sure there was probably a lot more said in that conversation than those things,” Thomas told the Daily News. the day after the quotes were published. “Again, we understand the place we play in, we understand the market we're in, and I think Reggie also said that we have the potential to be a playoff team, too, so it depends on what comment you decide to look at."
Asked what his reaction would be the next time he crossed paths with Miller, Thomas said:
"I'll give him a big hug and a kiss, and say, 'What's up?' "
QUOTE OF THE WEEK
![]() |
"What was going through my mind was that I am a Christian,'' Dunleavy said. "I go to church and God may not be a Pacer fan, but he gives us fairness and he was going to come through and basketball never lies. I knew he was going to miss one of those, but it was disappointing that it ever got to that point.''
Smith missed the third free throw, which would’ve resulted in a tie.
INTERNOTES …





















