By Steve Aschburner, for NBA.com
Posted Feb 25 2011 2:35PM
Within the larger confines of The Race To The MVP, a dash to the More Valuable Player Award broke out Thursday night at Chicago's United Center.
That's More Valuable, rather than Most, because in this case it was a comparative competition rather than a superlative. The Race is a generous form, with spots for 10 MVP candidates even though the NBA's official ballot allows for only five. But with Derrick Rose and LeBron James running 1-2 -- in that order -- atop The Race for weeks now, it seemed appropriate that the showdown of their teams, the Chicago Bulls vs. the Miami Heat, might narrow the MVP focus in laser-like fashion.
Members of the committee, all of whom were in the house, weren't the only ones who saw it that way.
"So would it be safe to say that the result of tonight's big matchup between Miami vs. Chicago (in Chicago) will determine who the #1 ranked guy on the Race is tomorrow?" e-mailer "Yoon Mi" wrote. "I can't wait cause it is going to be an awesome game and a possible playoff preview. "Personally I agree with ESPN's award watch that LeBron is the MVP right now but I agree with you on the other 2-10 rankings. Hopefully LBJ can prove me right tonight with a big road win and send Chicago to a second consecutive loss. Cheers!"
Cheers back at Yoon Mi. But things didn't quite work out that way.
Truth be told, when the week began, the committee was fully intending to flip Rose and James for this edition. Seeing both in action at All-Star Weekend was a reminder -- a mostly needless reminder, though -- that James is the better player by a wide margin. If the NBA were forming tomorrow, in a newly contracted version with 12 teams in the biggest and most glamorous markets, the undisputed No. 1 pick playground-style would be the Heat's Mack truck of a small forward.
Slice it another way and the result is the same: If Chicago or any other team with a player in The Race wanted to pry James loose from Miami via a trade, it would have to offer something like its MVP candidate, its second-best player, maybe another starter, a rotation guy and multiple draft picks. Most teams wouldn't even have enough assets to get a deal done. No one else in the league would extract a higher price.
But that's a different debate. Revisiting old ground, the MVP isn't just the "Most Outstanding Player of 2010-11" award, nor does it automatically belong to the best player on the best team. It is a mysterious recipe of factors, brewed in a cauldron of intangibles, and boosting the performance of a team with fewer stars than the next guy's is part of the mix.
The curious thing Thursday in Chicago's 93-89 victory on TNT was that Rose, more than on most nights, seemed to have plenty of help. Forward Luol Deng -- who would have been willingly discarded in a preseason Carmelo Anthony trade if the Bulls had been willing to part with center Joakim Noah -- had 20 points, 10 rebounds and five assists against Miami and outplayed James in the second half.
Carlos Boozer made up for his usual spotty defense with 16 points and nine rebounds, while the Heat's Chris Bosh -- frequently pestered by Noah -- shot 1-for-18. Rose's bench gave their team 22 points to Miami's two. Backup center Omer Asik (whom the Bulls wouldn't give up in a proposed Courtney Lee deal) had a game-high 11 rebounds in 21 minutes.
Still, in the end, it was Rose who swung the game Chicago's way. And he did it with James defending him down the stretch.
Statistically, the Heat star's numbers were gaudier: 29 points, 10 rebounds, five assists, two steals and a block on 12-of-21 shooting, including a couple remarkable breakout dunks in the opening minutes. Rose finished with 26 points, five rebounds and six assists on 9-of-24.
But there was Rose's 22-footer, after a loose ball run down by Deng, with Dwyane Wade switching to cover that sent Miami into a timeout down 89-84 with 1:06 left. The normally placid Rose exploded with some excited words that he shyly would not repeat afterwards. Then at 89-89 in the final half minute, Rose penetrated, drew Wade over to help out James, then found the man Wade vacated over in the corner. It was Deng, whose 3-pointer gave Chicago control of the final 16 seconds and the game.
Earlier in the day, two of James' teammates -- Bosh and Juwan Howard -- said that they leaned toward Rose in the MVP race (NBA players don't actually vote but their opinions on the matter rightfully carry much weight). "LeBron has won the last two and is my teammate," Bosh said. "But Derrick has had a phenomenal season. ... I think it's close. But I think I would give it to Derrick if I were a voter. ... If you take him out of the lineup, there's no telling what you get."
Wade stayed true to his school, admitting teammate "bias" in picking James.
Later, before tipoff, James was pretty gracious about it.
"The award isn't named after myself. There's guys who came before me and there's guys that come after me who'll win the award. It's not like it's mine," the two-time reigning MVP said. "I just go out there and do what I do every night to help our team win basketball games.
"Like I always keep saying, team success comes with individual accolades. D-Rose is having an unbelievable season. He's doing everything -- and more -- to help this team be a contender. There's no way you can mention the MVP race without mentioning his name."
Afterward, to even the scales, the committee hit the Chicago locker room in search of Rose teammates who might throw their MVP support to James.
Result: Massive fail. Rose will rattle off several names when asked, but at the season's start he volunteered himself as a top MVP pick. Deng laughed and waved off the question. Ronnie Brewer then broke down the Bulls' dynamics and the heavy-lifting Rose has done.
"No, I'm going to stay with my teammate," Ronnie Brewer said. "I'm not going to say somebody's more deserving. I still think if Joakim and Booz had not got hurt, they would have been All-Stars. I think Luol Deng was very deserving of an All-Star berth. Unfortunately, they didn't get it, so we had one All-Star. But we were still competing as one of the top teams in the East.
"You look at Boston and Miami -- they had four and three guys, respectively. The way that he's carried this team and made everybody better across the board, there's no other person who deserves than D-Rose."
Here are this week's candidates, with a clear Top 2 and Eight Admirable Others:
Dropping out: Russell Westbrook, Oklahoma City (No. 8 last week); Chris Paul, New Orleans (No. 9), and Carmelo Anthony, Denver/New York (No. 10).
Honorable mention: Paul; Westbrook; Anthony; LaMarcus Aldridge, Portland; Jason Kidd, Dallas.
Steve Aschburner has written about the NBA for 25 years. You can e-mail him here and follow him on twitter. The views on this page do not necessarily reflect the views of the NBA, its clubs or Turner Broadcasting.
|Shaq Week Invades NBA TV|
NBA TV will premiere Shaq Week featuring a full week of programming starring Shaquille O'Neal, beginning Monday, August 29.
|GameTime: At The Buzzer|
Rick Kamla and Dennis Scott discuss Carmelo Anthony going to the corner store in a bathrobe emblazoned with his name.
|GameTime: Buy Or Sell|
Dennis Scott and Rick Kamla discuss off-season developments, deciding whether or not to buy or sell.
|GameTime: Isiah Thomas|
NBA TV's Isiah Thomas calls in to GameTime to discuss the tragedy that took place in Chicago this week.
|GameTime: Shaq Week|
Ahead of Shaq's induction into the Basketball Hall of Fame, NBA TV will run an interview between Shaq and Ernie Johnson discussing Shaq's Hall of Fame career.