Posted Jan 14 2010 2:59PM
WEST PALM BEACH, Florida (AP) -- An antitrust lawsuit against Dwyane Wade should be dismissed because the NBA star has the right to control licensing of his name and image, Wade's attorneys told a federal judge on Thursday.
But lawyers for Wade's former partners in a failed restaurant venture contended that the Miami Heat guard violated antitrust laws by walking away, and they want $90 million in damages from Wade. They argue that when Wade withdrew permission to license his name, he illegally squelched competition for valuable personalized items such as signed basketballs, T-shirts and hats.
Wade's attorneys told U.S. District Judge Kenneth Marra that a celebrity has never been accused in a U.S. court of wrongly monopolizing his own memorabilia market. Wade's decision to terminate his deal with partners in the D. Wade's Place chain was within his rights to license his own image as he sees fit, attorney Robert Turken said.
"If you have a right to give a license, you have a right not to give a license. If you have a right not to give a license, you have a right to take it away," Turken said.
Marra said he would rule on the request to dismiss the case "as soon as possible" but didn't specify when.
Bruce Fein, attorney for the former partners, said Wade's decision to abandon the project triggered the antitrust violation because it removed a competitor in the memorabilia business. D. Wade's Place was envisioned as a national chain of upscale sports restaurants that would sell Wade items at its locations and on the Internet. Only two Florida locations opened and they quickly closed.
Wade's contract gave the venture rights to use his name and likeness forever, Fein said.
Wade ranks fifth in the NBA with a scoring average of 27 points per game, and he has lucrative deals with Nike's Jordan Brand, T-Mobile and Gatorade.
Wade, who turns 28 on Sunday, did not attend the hearing. He did take part in meetings last year aimed at reaching a settlement, but the talks hit an impasse.
|Through the Lens: USA Basketball Pracice, Day 2|
Take a super slow-motion look at the second day of practice for USA Basketball.
|All-Access: Paul George at USA Basketball Practice|
Listen in as Paul George wears a mic to the second day of USA Basketball practice.
|Top 10 Plays: 2014 NBA Summer League|
Check out the top 10 plays from the Orlando and Las Vegas 2014 NBA Summer League.
|All-Access: Kyrie Irving at USA Basketball Practice|
Go behind-the-scenes with Kyrie Irving as he participates in USA Basketball practice.
|Sekou Smith on the Central Division|
Sekou Smith talks about the new competitive balance in the Central Division.